Destination Guide Refine search by clicking on selections below Cuisine Seafood (9) American (8) Contemporary (3) Italian (3) Bars, Clubs + Pubs (2) Asian (1) Bagels & Donuts (1) Continental (1) Desserts (1) Fastfood (1) See all cuisine
 Title Keyword
| ||||||||||
| LIST VIEW | MAP VIEW | SORT BY NAME | STAR | PRICE |
| East by Northeast 51 Edgemere Rd., Montauk, NY 631.668.2872 |  |
I haven't been this disappointed in a restaurant in a very long time. We've given this place two chances and they've completely failed to live up to the very little expectation we had for them in the first... more
| REVIEWS (13) |
| Lobster Roll 1980 Montauk Hwy., Montauk, NY 631.267.3740 | |
We’d already eaten that morning, but we couldn’t resist trying a bite from the famous trailer cafe while we settled in to watch the surfers take to the waves. I’d heard about the Ditch Witch’s excellent breakfast... more
| REVIEWS (12) |
| John's Pancake House Main St., Montauk, NY 631.668.2383 | |
If you've ever wondered where the surfers go after a tough morning of dropping in and then hanging ten, look no further than this pancake palace with a touch of the old west. After all, where else are you going to get Ha... more
| REVIEWS (6) |
| Harvest on Fort Pond 11 S. Emory St., Montauk, NY 631.668.5574 | |
its a great place for groups, big and little, since everything is plentiful enough for sharing. true to its setting, seafood is best here, from the delicate, garlicky mussels to the tender, nicely-seasoned swordfish meda... more
| REVIEWS (6) |
| Duryea's Dock 65 Tuthill Rd., Montauk, NY 631.668.2410 | |
This rustic byob features outdoor seating where you must go for the sunset. You order and wait for the pick up window to announce that your super fresh seafood fest is ready. Expect paper plates and nothing special for s... more
| REVIEWS (3) |
| Napeague Stretch 2095 Montauk Hwy., Montauk, NY 631.267.6980 | |
you might feel as if you are standing on the deck of a fabulous yacht inside this sleek restaurant with gleaming wooden floors and teak and white-canvas accents. the three-sided bar serves infused cocktails such as fresh... more
| REVIEWS (2) |
| Manucciis 440 W. Lake Dr., Montauk, NY 631.668.4455 | |
we were in montauk 7/12-15-went to manuccis monday nite. had to wait 40 min for a table(make reservations!)
| REVIEWS (2) |
| Gosman's Dock 500 W. Lake Dr., Montauk, NY 631.668.5330 | |
several friends recommended gosmans so we thought it was a safe bet for good seafood. it is perfectly situated on the water and is open/airy
| REVIEWS (2) |
| Breakwater Cafe 32 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 631.668.3949 | |
| Cyril's Fish House 2167 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 631.267.7993 | |
|
|
 |